MOSFET vs BJT:
When we are studying about Power semiconductor devices, we will start from Diode then Bipolar Junction Transistor and then MOSFET and so on…
It is good to know that what are the advantages and disadvantages of MOSFET over BJT.
It is interesting to know why Now a days Power Electronics Design Engineers prefer-MOSFET over BJT in their applications.
Power-MOSFET has several features different from that of Power BJT. Those are discussed in this post. Before proceeding further, it is good to know about the Power Mosfet and Power BJT. Our earlier posts explains about these topics.
Click here to know about the basics of Power BJT
Click here to know about Power MOSFET.
(i) Power-MOSFET(Metal Oxide Semiconductor Field Effect Transistor) has lower switching losses but its on-resistance and conduction losses are more. In contrast to this, BJT(Bidirectional Junction Transistor) has higher switching losses but lower conduction losses.
Why switching losses are less in MOSFETs?
MOSFETs are majority carrier device, means flow of current inside the device is carried out either flow of electrons(N-Channel MOSFET) or flow of holes(P-Channel MOSFET). So when the device turns off, reverse recombination process won’t happen. It leads to short turn ON/OFF times. As switching time is less, loss associated with it less.
So for high frequency applications, where the switching loss is major impact in total power loss of the circuit, this device is the right choice.
On the other hand, for applications having lower operating frequencies BJT is superior.
Voltage control or Current control:
(ii) MOSFET is voltage controlled device whereas BJT is current controlled device.
Mosfet operation is controlled by gate-source voltage(VGS). In BJT, the operation is controlled by base current. As we know that providing constant voltage is easier than providing constant current in electrical circuits. So Mosfet’s gate drive circuit is less complex than BJT’s base drive circuit.
(iii) MOSFET has positive temperature coefficient for resistance. So parallel operation is easy. BJT has negative temperature coefficient, so current-sharing resistors are mandatory during parallel operation of BJTs.
Secondary Breakdown Issue:
(iv) The major difference between Power-MOSFET and Power-BJT is, that the Power-MOSFET do not have the secondary breakdown problem whereas Power-BJT suffers from secondary breakdown issue.
Summary of Comparison between BJT and MOSFET:
|1||It is a Bipolar Device||It is majority carrier Device|
|2||Current control Device||Voltage control Device.|
|3||Output is controlled by controlling base current||Output is controlled by controlling gate voltage|
|4||Negative temperature coefficient||Positive temperature coefficient|
|5||So paralleling of BJT is difficult.||So paralleling of this device is easy.|
|6||Dive circuit is complex. It should provide constant current(Base current)||Dive circuit is simple. It should provide constant voltage(gate voltage)|
|7||Losses are low.||Losses are higher than BJTs.|
|8||So used in high power applications.||Used in low power applications.|
|9||BJTs have high voltage and current ratings.||They have less voltage and current ratings.|
|10||Switching frequency is lower than MOSFET.||Switching frequency is high.|
Saturation in MOSFET and Transistor:
How does the concept of saturation differ in MOSFET with BJT?
(1) In BJT the base region is flooded with carriers so that it is driven in saturation. But there is not saturation region in mosfet.
(2) In mosfets there is a ohmic region. When higher gate voltage is applied, the MOSFET is driven in ohmic region. But there is no such region in BJT.
(3) BJT is ON in the saturation region and MOSFET is ON in the ohmic region. Ohmic region induces channel in the body region of MOSFET. Then current flows from drain to source.
(4) In BJT, the saturation means, base is completely flooded with carriers. Therefore current flows from collector to emitter.
Ohmic region can disappear fast when gate voltage is removed in the MOSFET. But in BJT, the stored charges in base are removed slowly.
Power MOSFET – Safe Operating Area